Reading “what is art?” by Leo Tolstoy changed what art means to me

About a week ago I started to reread “what is art?” by Leo Tolstoy after trying to read it once when I wasn’t in the right mind-space for it and I am so glad I did because now, every single page of this book lives in my mind rent free. The book is Tolstoy answering the question in the title, giving his opinion on the takes of other writers, artists and philosophers that had previously done so and adding his take based on his personal experience with the arts. And I must say, reading this book took longer for me to finish a book of this small amount of pages because I was constantly pausing to reread, highlight and write notes on so many passages.
The truth is, and I think Tolstoy would agree, that art is not a simple thing to define in an objective way. There are so many facets to what art is, so many of those I’ve honestly never thought of until reading some of the different takes in this book, for example, what is art in the spiritual sense? Or in the physical sense? Some even made mentions of the metaphysical, and that alone made me understand more about art in a matter of seconds that what I had given it thought in years.
For me, art had been a tool, a way for me to express what is in my heart and mind but can’t merely just said in simple terms. I didn’t think too much about “art” as I did about feelings, and thoughts, what the art was supposed to communicate. But now I think that after taking time to sit with myself and Tolstoy and simply listen to all the different ways that different people had defined art and what it does to the soul, and how its all around us, it has really deepened my understanding of the art I create as well, why I create it, where it really comes from.
So many of the definitions of what art is quoted in this book really are engraved in my mind. And even though Tolstoy (and i agree) finds them to be incomplete takes, for the most part they are not incorrect. And I’ve made a combination of those into my own little “Frankenstein’s monster” of an answer to the question of “what is art?”.
I believe nature serves as a genesis for all human art because there is no art without nature, without the bodies and sceneries, without the symmetry and perfect ratios, without the physics or the perfect color contrasts and combinations. Everything humans have ever created can be traced to origin points of inspiration, whether conscious or unconscious, to nature. Truth is, art is all around us and we get to connect the dots in ways that may only be visible to us, thanks to a combination of factors personal to each one of us, and we take this new image we found and, through different media we make it visible to others. And while all can see what we made, only those who can connect dots in a similar way can also feel what we try to communicate with our art.
Lastly, I want to share my favorite of the theories and opinions of some artists that Tolstoy quoted to show the contradicting opinions they had.
“The object of logical knowledge is truth; the object of aesthetic (that is sensuous) knowledge is beauty. Beauty is the perfect (the absolute) perceived by the senses, truth is the perfect perceived by reason. The good is the perfect attained by the moral will.” -Baumgarten
“Art consists in the uniting into one of the beauties scattered through nature. The ability to see these beauties is taste; the ability to unite them in one whole is artistic genius”. -Pagano
“True and real beauty is the manifestation of the idea in an individual form; and art is the realization of beauty in the real of the free human spirit. The highest stage of art is the art of life”. -Krause
So, romanticize life




Comments